sportnews full logo

Top 10 Premier League Penalty Takers of All Time

The Premier League has featured many players known for their calmness and accuracy when taking penalties. Leading the pack is Alan Shearer with 56 goals from the spot, followed by Yaya Touré, who impressively never missed a penalty. Other notable names include Matt Le Tissier and Harry Kane, both admired for their consistency. Meanwhile, emerging talents like Cole Palmer and Erling Haaland are carrying on this tradition with remarkable records.

Scoring from penalties is a vital skill in football, and many forwards have relied on it to boost their goal tallies. The Premier League, as one of the most competitive leagues, has seen numerous players demonstrate exceptional nerve and precision under pressure. This list highlights those who stand out as some of the best penalty takers ever to grace the league.

Ranking of the Top 10 Penalty Scorers

  • Rank: 10, Player: Bukayo Saka, Clubs: Arsenal, Years Active: 2019–Present, Penalties Scored: 12
  • Rank: 9, Player: James Beattie, Clubs: Southampton, Everton, Sheffield United, Stoke City, Years Active: 1998–2010, Penalties Scored: 16
  • Rank: 8, Player: Callum Wilson, Clubs: Bournemouth, Newcastle United, Years Active: 2014–Present, Penalties Scored: 16
  • Rank: 7, Player: Erling Haaland, Clubs: Manchester City, Years Active: 2022–Present, Penalties Scored: 20
  • Rank: 6, Player: Danny Murphy, Clubs: Liverpool, Charlton, Tottenham, Fulham, Years Active: 1997–2013, Penalties Scored: 18
  • Rank: 5, Player: Harry Kane, Clubs: Tottenham Hotspur, Years Active: 2012–2023, Penalties Scored: 33
  • Rank: 4, Player: Cole Palmer, Clubs: Manchester City, Chelsea, Years Active: 2021–Present, Penalties Scored: 18
  • Rank: 3, Player: Matt Le Tissier, Clubs: Southampton, Years Active: 1992–2002, Penalties Scored: 25
  • Rank: 2, Player: Yaya Touré, Clubs: Manchester City, Years Active: 2010–2018, Penalties Scored: 11
  • Rank: 1, Player: Alan Shearer, Clubs: Blackburn Rovers, Newcastle United, Years Active: 1992–2006, Penalties Scored: 56

Profiles of Premier League's Finest Penalty Experts

10. Bukayo Saka (Arsenal)

Once remembered for a missed penalty in the Euro 2020 final, Bukayo Saka has since grown into one of Arsenal's most reliable penalty takers. His conversion rate stands at an impressive 92%, having scored 12 out of 13 penalties in the Premier League. With over 223 appearances, he's become a key figure in his club's attack.

9. James Beattie (Southampton, Everton, and more)

James Beattie made a mark with his penalty prowess, scoring 16 goals from 17 attempts across several Premier League clubs. His only miss came in 2006 but didn’t cost his team much. His calmness in front of goal was evident throughout his 270 league appearances.

8. Callum Wilson (Bournemouth, Newcastle United, West Ham)

Callum Wilson has been a dependable forward with a near-perfect penalty record, netting 16 times from 17 attempts. His composure in high-pressure moments contributed to his success, making him a trusted penalty taker for multiple clubs.

7. Erling Haaland (Manchester City)

Known for his relentless goal-scoring, Erling Haaland has converted 20 penalties out of 23 attempts in the Premier League. His misses are rare, and he remains a key figure in Manchester City's attacking threat, regardless of match stakes.

6. Danny Murphy (Liverpool, Charlton, Tottenham, Fulham)

Midfielder Danny Murphy missed just one penalty during his Premier League career, scoring 18 goals from the spot. His ability to remain composed made him one of the most respected penalty takers of his era.

5. Harry Kane (Tottenham Hotspur)

Current Bayern Munich striker Harry Kane scored 33 penalties in the Premier League with an 89% conversion rate. Despite a few misses, his reputation as a dependable scorer from the spot is well established.

4. Cole Palmer (Manchester City, Chelsea)

Cole Palmer was perfect from the penalty spot for a long time, scoring 18 out of 19 attempts before being denied once. His ability to handle pressure in big games shines through his penalty record.

3. Matt Le Tissier (Southampton)

A legend at Southampton, Matt Le Tissier scored 24 out of 25 penalties in the Premier League. Nicknamed “Le God,” his precision and calmness in front of goal earned him a unique place among the greats.

2. Yaya Touré (Manchester City)

The only player on this list with a perfect penalty record, Yaya Touré scored 11 penalties for Manchester City without missing any. His composed approach and technique made him almost unbeatable from the spot.

1. Alan Shearer (Blackburn Rovers, Newcastle United)

Alan Shearer leads with 56 penalty goals in the Premier League. Although he missed more than ten penalties in his career, his sheer number of successful spot kicks and clutch performances make him the top penalty taker in Premier League history.

FAQs About Premier League Penalty Takers

  • Who is the Premier League's greatest penalty taker?Alan Shearer holds the record for most penalties scored in the league.
  • Is Erling Haaland among the top 10 Premier League penalty takers?Yes, Haaland ranks seventh on the all-time list.
  • Who are the top three Premier League penalty takers?They are Alan Shearer, Yaya Touré, and Matt Le Tissier.
  • Where does Erling Haaland rank among the best penalty takers?He is seventh on the Premier League all-time penalty scorers list.

Related Articles